justice, peace and creation news
Table of Contents

Issue 21, 2002

Editorial

What price security?
Pamela K. Brubaker

Another world is possible
Susan George

Contemporary social movements
Theoretical reflection and experience
Wim Dierckxsens

The search for fair finance
Patrick Bond

Out of the vicious cycle of debt
Eric Toussaint

A new financial instrument to apply a new investment ethic
Shyamala Ariarajah

Bye, bye poverty reduction strategy papers and hello good governance
Alejandro Bendaña

Land does not belong to us. We belong to the land
William Stanley

The new partnership for Africa's development (NEPAD)
Rogate R. Mshana

World Summit on Sustainable development

SISTERS
Marillia Schüller

Publications & announcements





justice, peace and creation news

ECHOES is an occasional publication of the World Council of Churches' cluster on "Issues and Themes", Justice, Peace & Creation team.

Publisher
The executive Director of the Cluster on "Issues and Themes", Rev. Dr Samuel Kobia

Publication Staff Team:
Susie Harrison, Bob Scott, Miriam Reidy-Prost,

Layout and design:
Marie Arnaud Snakkers

Printed on environmentally friendly paper by Imprimer Presses Centrales SA, Lausanne

Cover photo:
Peter Williams / WCC

Articles for future publications are welcome.

Articles published in ECHOES are WCC copyright, however permission will be granted to reproduce most material on application.

All correspondence and inquiries should be directed to:

Justice, Peace & Creation
ECHOES
World Council of Churches
150 rte de Ferney
P.O. Box 2100
1211 Geneva 2, Switzerland

Tel: (41 22) 791 6111
Fax: (41 22) 791 6409



Printed copies of ECHOES can be ordered from the JPC Publications Office of the WCC. The average cost of producing and mailing ECHOES is US$5.00 per copy (equivalent to approx 7.-Sfr.). Readers who can afford it are strongly encouraged to contribute. However, please note that any contributions under Sfr.20.- (US$15.00) actually cost more to cash than is worth.
Individuals willing to express their commitment to the Justice, Peace and Creation team may also contribute in the same way. Please make payment either by cheque in the name of the WCC, or to the following bank accountrs, with a very clear mention that it is for ECHOES-magazine, JPC.

Lloyds Bank Plc
39 Threadneedle Street
P.O. Box 217
London EC3P 3BT
Account No. 1101875 (£sterling)

The Skandiviska Enskilda Banken
Box 40085
S-10640 Stockhold
Account No. 5277-10 002 53

Bankers Trust Company
1, Bankers Trust Plaza
130 Liberty St., 21st floor
P.O. Box 318
Church Street Station
New York, N.Y. 10015 - USA
Account No. 04-814-909

Toronto Dominion Bank
Toronto Dominion Centre Branch

55 King Street w. & Bay Street
Toronto, Ontario M5K 1A2, Canada
Account No. 0690-0988974

Echoes from elsewhere

An introduction to ECHOES magazine in reactions, facts and issues from all over the world


Whose DNA?

Tonga & Iceland, biotech, ownership and consent

In November 2000, Australian biotech company Autogen announced it had secured the exclusive rights to the entire gene pool of the Tongan people through a contract signed with Tonga's Ministry of Health. Due to adverse public reaction in Tonga, Autogen is supposed to have withdrawn its interest in August 2001. However, other biotech companies are interested in the Tongan people because they are genetically isolated. If Autogen has indeed withdrawn its interest, it is one battle won in the ongoing struggle by Indigenous peoples to assert their sovereignty over their own resources.

The agreement was originally negotiated without any publicity or public debate in Tonga. By comparison, the consent given by Icelandic people to their agreement with the commercial firm de-Code, was achieved after being hotly debated in the parliament and the media, and was described variously as "democratic" and "acrimonious, polarised and pitting laymen against experts". When informed consent becomes a political activity, which questions take priority? Will biotech take "no" for an answer, if that is the decision?

Co-presented by Lopeti Senituli and Margaret Boyes, Australasian Bioethics Association Annual Conference, Adelaide, February 14-16 2002.


Five years after civil war, Guatemala is still waiting for the fruits of peace

Guatemala City (ENI).Guatemala's civil war came to an end just over five years ago, but the country has yet to enjoy the peace that most hoped would follow in the wake of the 36-year armed conflict. Political parties are weak, civil society remains fragmented, and the government appears incapable of meeting society's basic needs or of extending democratic reforms. "The peace process has stalled because there is no political will for it to prosper, because there are sectors of the powerful who are addicted to unjust economic and political structures, and they don't want to see things change," the Rev. José Pilar Alvarez, a Lutheran pastor in the eastern Guatemalan city of Zacapa, told ENI.


Church agencies demand EU sanctions against Israel

Geneva (ENI). As European Union foreign ministers discuss the crisis in the Middle East at a meeting in Luxembourg, church organisations are demanding that the EU impose sanctions against Israel. The general secretary of the World Council of Churches (WCC), Konrad Raiser, has called on the EU ministers to suspend an agreement that gives privileged trade status to Israel. Similar calls have come from Christian Aid, the church aid agency in Britain and Ireland, and from Aprodev, an association of 15 European Protestant, Anglican and Orthodox development agencies. Last week the European Parliament voted to suspend the trade agreement with Israel, but the vote is not binding on EU foreign ministers.


Filipino church leaders warn against increased US military presence

Manila (ENI).Church leaders in the Philippines have condemned plans to increase the number of United States troops in the country. The Philippine church leaders claim that the escalation of the US war against terrorism here may lead to greater antagonism between Filipino Muslims and Christians and the further erosion of Philippine sovereignty.


Canadian church campaign pressures oil company on climate change

Vancouver (ENI). A Canadian ecumenical campaign is targeting one of Canada's biggest oil companies which is opposed to a major United Nations^' agreement on climate change. Representatives of the campaign, including Lois Wilson, a former president of the World Council of Churches (WCC) and former moderator of the United Church of Canada (UCC), took part this week in the shareholders' meeting of Imperial Oil, one of Canada's biggest integrated petro-leum companies. Wilson, who has just retired as a Canadian senator and has had national assignments on energy-related matters, questioned the policies of Imperial Oil with regard to climate change and future energy options.